- "Mr. Mandelbaum! Thanks a lot for coming to Amherst, this
documentary
told people a lot about the ideas of feelings, history and memory. For
people who live far away such documentaries is the only source of geting
the correct knowledge." M.
- "Juan’s visit to my classroom to discuss violence and memory was
hugely valuable to our curriculum. His documentary, as a memorial for
the desaparecidos, helped us learn about the process of reconciliation.
Juan’s patient and open minded nature, together with his great
preparation to discuss the questions that the students had prepared for
him, created an important learning experience for the Spanish students,
who, after seeing his documentary and exploring the history of
Argentina, could only but connect with the people of Argentina.
Important questions are now being discussed in the classroom, such as
how do we remember? Whom? Why? How? When? Thanks Juan, for sharing your
journey." Laura Bravo Melguizo, Spanish Instructor at The Winsor
School
- "I was very moved by this documentary. Mr. Mandelbaum, thank you
for coming to the Hot Springs Documentary Festival 2009-Arkansas."
Victoria
- "I was very tired one night switching channels when by chance I came
across the documentary. As exhausted as I was I could not stop watching
because I was born and raised in Ecuador until I came to the US in 1979.
I remember a large number of argentinians settling in Ecuador and the
many sad stories they brought with them. Many thanks to all who made
this documentary possible because we should never forget and we should
continue striving to get some form of justice for the families of the
disappeared and for our future leaders to know that we must never let
this happen again." Giovanni M.
- "I knew about the disappearances at the time because a refugee from
Argentina was attending my graduate school. It was chilling because she
described all of the things that she did as a youth active in her church
to help the poor that caused many of her friends to be murdered under
the dictatorship. These were the same kinds of activities that I had
been doing as a youth in my church in the United States. As I saw the
photos of the young people in this movie I thought of how much I had in
common with them.
"I also remember the gatherings of the courageous mothers of the
disappeared who began to shame the dictatorship. And that this
brought new awareness to what had happened. Very inspiring. But I also
saw a film that described how the babies of the disappeared were adopted
into the very families that had authorized and participated in murder.
I wonder what that knowledge has done to them as adults?
"Finally, I continue to feel the chill when I heard elected officials in
the USA say that it's time to "move on" from this country's recent
practice of torture without fully investigating these practices. Until
this investigation is done, the higher moral standard we once supposed
about ourselves is no more. And the smiling Kissingers of this world
rest easy in their beds at night while weeping mothers look at the
photos of their murdered children." Jim R.
- "I was immensely moved by your documentary and the way it created
both a personal and an historical narrative, hand in hand. Kudos to you
and your team, beautiful piece that celebrates the spirit of all
generations involved." Gabriela B.
- "I watched the PBS presentation of your film last night. I was
deeply moved, and today I have spent a great deal of time looking for
more information. I plan to read some books on this horrible time in
history. We must never forget, and as U.S.A. citizens, we must speak
out against tyranny and injustice, and against those politicians in our
own country who would support these kinds of repressive governments."
Marielena
- "I found this story very moving, very sad and very disturbing. As an
American I never knew anything about it until tonite. I am not ashamed
to say that thru much of it I was in tears. It doesn't surprise me that
the Nixon/Ford administration turned a blind eye towards the
disappearance, torture and murder of 30,000 people. It is very sad to
think that the U.S. could have done something and instead did
nothing. Many thanks to Juan for his expose. It really touched my
heart." Kevin M.
- "Mr. Mandelbaum, your documentary was intense and powerful. Thanks
for opening my eyes for this terrible truth...." K.
- "Thank you for making this moving and important documentary." Marcia B.
- "I need to say thank you to everyone who helped realize this
documentary. Even though those words are not enough." Dani M.
- "There's a photograph hidden in Andrew Witkin's exhibit at LaMontagne Gallery. It's a print made from a digital photo of a scan of a Polaroid, and it depicts, in case you can't discern the image through so many generations, a dried rose. Witkin has placed a list over it, bits of text responding to 'Nuestros Desaparecidos,' a documentary about victims of political oppression in Buenos Aires: 'faces of old friends,' 'no longer far away,' 'to be silent.'"
from Words of art. Boston Globe. Cate
McQuaid.
- "[The film] is heartbreakingly sad at times, incredibly powerful, and really makes you glad to be an American."
from her blog entry "Something really scary". theotherhilary.
- "In any theater you sit down willing to have your mind and emotions taken on whatever rollercoaster the director of the film has in mind, but this film was a wrenching experience to watch... If you're young or depressed, this is not the film for you, but if you identify as a world citizen responsible to know recent history and work for human rights, this film will help you to understand Argentina."
from her blog entry "Nuestros Desaparecidos"/"Our Disappeared". Anne
Eggebroten.